I'll chime on as I have some firsthand experience with both in the third gens as well as with AT vs MT in both. Broken record but as so many have said, it comes down to intended use. That said, the only reason (apart from looks) for the long bed is if you actually have to haul stuff regularly...
Up for sale are a beautiful set of wheels and tires in nearly new condition. I purchased my new Tacoma with these installed and only have about 3,500 total miles on them. They have never seen anything apart from suburban streets. My off road plans for my truck simply call for a different...