Yea make sure you check ALL of your subscribed threads on all pages in your control panel. Then select no daily notifications in that drop down. I had this same problem but got it solved
Check the box in the upper right to select all... then delete/alter your notifications using the drop down box. You may need to do this for more than one page.
Check the box in the upper right to select all... then delete/alter your notifications using the drop down box. You may need to do this for more than one page.